Skip to main content

Obamacare and Religion


Obamacare and Religion

I am getting a bit tired of hearing all the rhetoric around the recent mandate by HHS that all health plans provide contraception etc. under the Obamacare law.

First did no one read this monster when it was passed? I have been talking with faith based organizations about this segment of the law since 2010. Did folks just think that this segment of the law was going to miraculously go away? Just like so many other sections of Obamacare this is another example of government over reaching in its regulations.

Here are the basics. The law says that all health plans have to provide coverage for contraception and abortion services by 2014. Faith based companies and other employers are clearly upset by this. The outrage seems clearly focused on the federal government trying to mandate that plans offer contraception even if they don’t wish to base it on religious beliefs. While I too am outraged at such presumption and hubris on the part of the Obama administration, we have much bigger problems.

The most serious of them is that the federal government is trying to circumvent existing legislation and regulation of certain health plans and force them to provide specific coverage. Specifically the feds are trying (and might be succeeding) in circumventing ERISA. A self-funded employer today has the choice of what benefits they want to offer in their health plans – as they should. This right is provided for under the terms of the ERISA regulations. Since 60% of all insured Americans are in self-funded plans this represents a massive shift in the private health insurance industry. It also sounds the alarm that our current administration has decided it is going to override ERISA and remove some of the founding principles without public or congressional approval. This is huge.

Let me be more specific. If Obamacare can decide at will what benefits will be federally mandated and can force those benefits into self-funded and insured plans then defacto we have a federal health plan or certainly the infancy of socialized healthcare. This is nothing short of outrageous.

So while I empathize with the religious groups and understand their indignation, the problem is actually bigger and much more devastating than just a difference in beliefs. We can’t run a competitive society if our largest industry is about to become a federal bureaucracy. Look at the condition of the Social Security and Medicare programs. Do we really think in our current economic condition nationalizing healthcare is a prudent fiscal strategy? 

Some may argue that now is the perfect time as we can cut costs and thus be more competitive on the world stage. Sadly this reasoning is fraught with several fallacies. First is that we can cut costs. When has a government run program of any kind been lower cost than a private sector venture? How long of a transition will this process be – 5 – 10 years? What happens to our economic results in the interim? How competitive will be during this transition? What will the national plan do that we can’t do privately? Sadly it will eventually implement all the reforms I have been advocating for more than a decade and maybe even more. Here are a few – they will quickly eliminate all PPO networks and opt for Medicare based pricing; they will ration healthcare over time; they will establish parity in drug pricing globally; they will decrease if not eliminate broker compensation; and they will eliminate state mandates in favor of a new set of federal mandates.

All of these reforms could be done in the private sector with the result being a rampant decrease in healthcare costs and a significant decrease in annual healthcare inflation. More on this is a subsequent blog.

So as the debate rages on Obamacare versus the religious organizations remember that this is the beginning of a very serious paradigm shift in healthcare reimbursement in the US and the impact on our economy will be devastating and long lasting.

Popular posts from this blog

Porsche Perspective

Before I start I must declare that I am a Ferrari owner, racer and lover. As such Porsche is normally an arch enemy. Most of the faithful from each camp very rarely see eye to eye and often avoid each other like the plague. So for me to write this piece on Porsche is a stretch and proves once and for all, above all I am just a true lover of all cars! Porsche has to be respected for their longevity, their racing prowess and their myopic market focus. Porsche's have been racing and winning for as long as I can remember and while they are not a Ferrari their racing pedigree is remarkable. Initially their claim to fame was the basic 911. This is still their bread and butter car and over the decades has been improved markedly. But I am not going to focus on the 911, the Panamera or Cayenne. Today I want to discuss the smaller, younger cousins - the Cayman and the Boxster. These two "entry level" Porsches are worth writing about. Porsche first made the Boxster in 1997 in an...
Read more

America Politics Gone Mad

In car racing we have a time in each season affectionately called the "Silly Season". For it is a time when all the trading and movement for the following season takes place. Driver switch teams or get fired, teams change suppliers or engines, teams switch leaders or engineers and race schedules and venues get selected or dumped. For racers it is time we expect to see massive change and sometimes surprises. Well it appears we are in the Silly Season in American politics. Yes we expect every 4 years that we will elect a President and it gets even sillier when we have a lame duck in the White house. (sorry no disrespect the President Obama although the title seems to fit). This time around it is the worst Silly Season I have ever seen. Actually we might want to rename it the Ridiculous Stupid Season. Have you been paying attention to the political circus in since late last year? Of course you have you can't avoid it no matter what you do. That right there is part of the...
Read more

American Hypocrits

I am confused and sad. All the polls for the last three years have shown the growing frustration and dislike the American people have for Congress. Actually, the approval rating for Congress is at 15% as of June. 9% was the lowest it has been in history and that happened late last year. Since 2012 we have averaged about 13% approval rating. I am one of those angry and frustrated Americans. The Congress has shown complete inability to conduct the business of the country and has bickered non stop since Obama took power. The have shown that their primary interest is their own political careers and not the will of the people. We are a laughing stock worldwide and this gridlock has affected our economy and foreign policy negatively. So here is the hypocrisy. If we hate the job the Congress is doing and we all agree that parties aside they are not performing to standards we the people have set, why don't we fire them? I just don't understand. We are a Democracy (really a republic...
Read more